English Trifle

S6 E9: The One Where Ross Got High

Friends, Warner Bros. Television, 1994.

Thanksgiving is a holiday built on tradition.

The turkey, the stuffing, the gathering of loved ones around a table to discover which family members have been lying to one another for the better part of a decade. And, of course, dessert, which usually doesn’t contain ground beef.

In Friends' “The One Where Ross Got High,” Monica is preparing Thanksgiving dinner for the gang and her parents, Jack and Judy Geller. There is, however, a small complication: her parents don't know she's living with Chandler. They also don't particularly like Chandler, although he has no idea why. Determined to win over his future in-laws, Chandler embarks on an increasingly unsuccessful charm offensive.

The source of their hostility eventually comes to light. Years earlier, while Ross was in college, his parents caught him smoking marijuana in his bedroom. Rather than accept responsibility, Ross informed them that Chandler had gotten high and jumped out the window. Apparently, the Gellers have spent the intervening years believing Chandler to be a corrupting influence on their otherwise upstanding son, whose personal accomplishments now include three marriages and the super-adult inability to accept responsibility for anything.

Meanwhile, Rachel has been entrusted with dessert, a responsibility that represents both a significant milestone in her personal development and a catastrophic lapse in Monica's judgment.

Determined to prove herself in the kitchen, Rachel selects a traditional English trifle, a layered dessert of ladyfingers, jam, custard, fruit, and whipped cream. Unfortunately, two pages of her recipe magazine have become stuck together, creating an unauthorized culinary collaboration between an English trifle and a shepherd's pie. The resulting confection includes raspberries, bananas, and a generous layer of beef sautéed with peas and onions.

Rachel, to her credit, questions none of this. The British have a long and storied history of unusual food combinations (lookin’ at you, jacket potato with tuna, corn, and cold cheese), and who is she to challenge centuries of culinary tradition?

Ross and Joey discover the mistake but decide that sparing Rachel's feelings is more important than protecting everyone's digestive tract. Thus begins an elaborate campaign of dessert-related deception, with guests enthusiastically praising the trifle before retreating to various rooms to dispose of it. Phoebe invokes her vegetarianism, Chandler takes his portion to the balcony, and Ross consumes his entire serving in a desperate effort to prevent Rachel from tasting it herself.

Joey, meanwhile, finds the dish perfectly acceptable. Custard is good. Jam is good. Meat is good.

But the evening's culinary catastrophe is only the beginning. Despite promising Monica and Chandler that he'll confess to his parents, Ross repeatedly postpones the conversation. Monica finally takes matters into her own hands, announcing that Ross was the one smoking marijuana all those years ago. This prompts an increasingly juvenile exchange of accusations between the Geller siblings, exposing everything from stolen pornography and a broken porch swing to Ross's secret Las Vegas marriage to Rachel. Ross retaliates by revealing that Monica and Chandler are living together, while Rachel, examining her recipe magazine, finally discovers that beef is not, in fact, a customary ingredient in English trifle.

Faced with several decades of family secrets delivered in approximately thirty seconds, Judy Geller demonstrates the crisis-management skills of a woman who has spent a lifetime raising these people. After expressing her disappointment in both children, she offers Chandler an unexpected apology. Far from being the bad influence they'd imagined, he's been Ross's loyal friend through years of questionable decisions and is now making Monica happy. Chandler, having done almost nothing to earn this sudden reversal beyond surviving dinner, is officially welcomed into the family.

By the end of the evening, the family's grievances are largely resolved, Chandler has earned the approval of Monica's parents, and Rachel has learned an important lesson about checking whether the pages of a cookbook are stuck together.

The trifle, however, has found its audience. Joey has recovered and eaten the abandoned portions, proving that even the most disastrous recipe can succeed if one lowers the definition of dessert far enough.

Make it! Rachel’s Traditional English Trifle Recipe from Salty Canary

 
Next
Next

Halloween Candy